ShodhKosh: Journal of Visual and Performing ArtsISSN (Online): 2582-7472
its origin and through various things surrounding it, and so the art
form projects its linkage with the community. Markose, B (n. d.) Thus, this research attempts to read Theyyam
as an archive of the subaltern community by dragging in the concept of archives
mentioned by the Indian scholar and feminist critic Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak
from her essay 'The Rani of Sirmur: An Essay in Reading the Archives.' Spivak
has done literary analysis of British records to demonstrate the inseparable of
language from the colonial/imperial project's goal of world domination. To
substantiate the arguments, she drags in the threat of a Himalayan queen (Rani)
to 'become sati' (That is, to immolate herself). It is interpreted as the
plight of subalterns of 'third world women' in particular. Almost all
dictionaries define an Archive as a collection of historical records or
documents that provides information about an institution, place, or group of
people. While Spivak is of the notion that it is the 19th-century European
historiography that defined archives as a repository of facts that is they are
constructing a fiction whose task is to produce a collection of the 'effects of
the real' and a 'misreading' of it produces a proper name of the thing which is
archived. An archive can be considered a literal substitute for the past, which
is already lost for the historian. When it is fetishized, it becomes the
repository of past traces and might be reconstructed. Thereby it creates a
mystifying experience, and it becomes subject to question. There might be things that are excluded and included in constructing an
archive. The things included in making an archive is dependent on the
historian's genealogy; that is, it might be because of the intellectual power
of the historian. It can also be due to the lack of evidence that the historian
gets on a matter, or it can be from the historian's analogy that certain
matters are excluded. Markose
and Thomas (2018) 1.1. POST OCCUPANCY EVALUATION (POE) 1.1.1. FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION Origin of Theyyam The pioneer
research scholars in Theyyam, K.K.N Kurup, and S. Settar traced the origin from
the Sangam period (300 BC-AD 250) and Velan Veryadal (Marks the beginning of
the dance tradition in Tamizhakam4)
in the 5th century. Later, the earliest form of Theyyam went through many
transformations as it got intertwined, overlapped, and even superimposed by
other traditions and spiritual expressions of people in those times. In the
Sangam period, the southern states were not divided as in the 21st century. It
extended from Venkatam (Andhra Pradesh) in the North to Kanyakumari (Tamil
Nadu) in the South and was known as Tamizhakam [4]
The art form took the form of Bhuta worship in the Upper North – Tulunad and
South Canara (At present in Karnataka) and in the South region, which comprises
South of Korappuzha (At present Kozhikode & Malappuram districts of Kerala),
and they called the art form as Thira. In Kolathunadu (At present, Kannur &
Kasaragod districts of Kerala), the art form is known as Theyyam. Thus, these
art forms share lots of similarities in common, from costumes to music etc. Not
just that, there is an exchange of characters portrayed in these art forms.
That is, such as Perumpuzha Achan, are related to the people & places of
Tulunadu, and vice versa, Theyyam such as Malaya Chamundi and Bappiriyan from
Kerala has become part of Bhuta worship. Bhuta worship is also practised by
Scheduled Castes such as Nalke, Panara, Koppala, Parava, Pambada, etc. Bhuta
cult, or the worship of the divine spirits through art forms, is believed to be
one of the ancient religious faiths of South India. Even at the present times
also these art forms are preserved and practised with their whole aura. Moi (1989) In Tamil
literature, there is a description of the five different habitats of the Sangam
period. When one tribal group enters the ecosystem of a particular thing, they
change the traditional occupation to adapt to the new ecosystem. Thereby, it
forms a new ecosystem based on the occupation, and even the deities worshipped
by these tribal groups also transform. In the Sangam period, the worshipping of
trees, animals and stones etc. were highly prevalent. Thus, later they included
the worship of dreadful forms of nature and even the dead heroes. This animist
mode of worship was highly influential on their religious beliefs. All these
kinds of practices show the kind of relationship man had with nature. Through
this animist mode of worship, they spiritually connected themselves with trees,
animals etc. Furthermore, later the religious institutions and certain trees
were associated with the worship of particular gods. This mode of
worship is well reflected in Theyyam, as it also worships ancestors and nature.
This itself shows that the tribal communities in Kerala still carries the
earlier forms of religious beliefs and practices. Dr Raghavan Payyanad, a
notable research scholar on Theyyam, mentions that "Theyyam should have
been a primitive form of ritual dance. The transformations in the social
structure, cultural transformations, were well reflected in it. At one point of
time, everyone should have participated in the ritual dance. Today a section of
people performs it with the support of all others for the wellbeing of one and
all." (Payyanad, Folklorinu Oru Padhanapadhati). With the evolution of
time, a transition has happened from worshipping the deities under the trees to
worshipping them inside a permanent well-constructed building called temples. Further evidence
can be traced from the human-like engraving of Edakkal caves in Wayanad, which
projects the practices held during the earlier phases of human life in that
area. According to writer Panchanan Mitran, these engravings date back to
B.C.1000 and B.C.700. While a research scholar Iravatham Mahadevan is of the
argument that it must have been done around 5000B.C. Some of the paintings and
petroglyphs highlight pre-historic elephants, various tools, and tribal
chieftains. The cravings of humans, animal-like figures, symbols convey
people's spirituality in the pre-historic era. Apart from that, there are
various kinds of engravings on the rock. It is considered to
be from the pre-literate, megalithic period to the literate, post-iron
Middle Ages. Some of the engravings convey the hunting and food gathering
systems. There are some engravings of human figures with men dancing in a
headdress, conveying the ancient devil dance. It is highly similar
to the costumes of Theyyam, and it is considered to be the beginning
phase of Theyyam. It is believed that the tribal communities of those times
used these kinds of rituals to convey their spirituality with natural and
supernatural things surrounding them. Payyanad
(1998) The worship of
the spirits can be traced from the Pre-Aryan era, and it is considered
indigenous to Indian culture. Writer Upadhyaya defines it as "Among the
religious faiths of the Dravidians of South India, the spirit cult or worship
of semi-divine spirits appear to be the most primitive one." (Upadhyaya,
"Renaissance in Tulu Literature"). Even now also the tribal
communities worship their ancestors on specific occasions through various kinds
of performances. These practices are done on the belief that their presence and
blessings will help them to attain prosperity. Apart from that, they believed
in the presence of their ancestors in forests, hills, trees etc., and they
worshipped them through various ritualistic practices. While some of these
practices are going on, at certain times, one of the people gathered there
would be possessed by the spirits, and they even worshipped them. These kinds
of spirit cults are practised in Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Tulunad. The worship of
the serpent was also common in those days, especially by the upper castes such
as Nairs, Namboothiris of Kerala, and they worshipped them in a different place
within the compounds of their house. Even today, these practices are also
followed in specific households and some temples. They are worshipped in
separate places within the temple premises. Serpent pantheons are represented
in Theyyam, and some of them are Naga Kali, Naga Bhagavathi, and Naga Rajavu.
Apart from that Tiger is another animal that is worshipped through Theyyam.
This practice was introduced as in those times the tribal communities were
terrified of tigers as they destroyed the paddy fields and attacked people and
so by pleasing them, they can save themselves from their attacks. Theyyam such
as Puliyanoor Kali, Puli Maran, and Puliyoor Kandan are some examples of it. Ancestral
worship is done based on the belief that they can influence the fortune of the
present and future generations. Generally, the worships for them are done on
new moon day on a specific month and sometimes, when the rituals are going on,
the spirits of the ancestors will possess some people. Certain Theyyam, such as
Achan, Dharma, Karnavar, Thondachan, etc., is performed to attain peace for the
ancestral spirits. They worshipped Earth as female energy during those times,
and it was seen as the principal deity. This was continued in the times of
Aryans, and the Gramadevathas[5]
worshipped by the Dravidians were transformed into kshetradevathas [6] whom the Aryans worshipped. Theyyam such as Rakta
Chamundi, Vira Chamundi, Madayil Chamundi etc. represents those pantheons. Later in the
land-owning system & plough agriculture introduced by the Kerala Brahmins
is based on the caste hierarchy (Chaturvarna), also known as Avakasham.
Furthermore, if the people deviated from the established laws, they were
punished by the upper castes. Under the new law, the right to perform Theyyam
was given to the Dalits. As they belonged to the lower strata in the
Chaturvarna, their voices were suppressed by the upper castes. In these times,
the cultural and religious beliefs of the dominant classes became strong.
However, the Dalit communities strongly followed their religious beliefs. So
Theyyam underwent many changes in indigenous communities, who were later
categorised as Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Theyyam is also known as
Theyyattom, Kaliyattom, Thira, Thirayattom, Kolam, Kolamkettal, etc. Certain
Theyyam is performed by artists belonging to certain castes. For example, Pottan
Theyyam is always performed by the Malaya community. Thus, it gave the Dalit
communities of Kerala a platform to put forth their problems. That is the main
reason the heroic figures represented in Theyyam are from their communities. Spivak
(2021) Analysis of
Various Things Surrounding Theyyam Sacred
Groves Theyyam
performances often take place at Kaavu, and it is very much different from the
mainstream temples. Kaavu, or the sacred grove, is a piece of garden or forest
land dedicated exclusively to a particular deity and is guarded over the years
in their interests. The statue of the deity is worshipped inside the temple or
shrine. Along with the worship of the deity, certain plants, and herbs, such as
the Banyan tree, Tulsi, etc., surrounding the Kaavu also get protected over the
years. As different
Kaavu have different deities, so their personal needs are also different. Based
on that, different kaavu have different kinds of ceremonies and poojas for
worshipping them. In Kaavu, Vedic deities are not worshipped, but the
indigenous deities such as Goddess Durga, Vishnumoorthy, Bhagavathy, Nagaraja
(Serpent King), Chithrakoodam, Yakshi, and Muthappan, etc. are worshipped. The
tradition of conserving nature can be traced from Pre-Vedic times in India. The
earliest food gathering people also worshipped nature, as their livelihood was
utterly dependent on it. Thus, Kaavu can be seen as a Pre-Vedic tradition
moulded into a new form of worship. This is well reflected in the subaltern
practice and also in Theyyam. Even the eco-scientists
have always acknowledged the practice of kaavu in the 21st century, where there
are many environmental issues like deforestation and global warming, etc.
Furthermore, it would be a kind solution for it. Byju Markose, a
notable research scholar in his book Rhizomatic Reflections: Discourse on
Religion and Theology, mentioned the embodiment of subaltern religious
sensibility within the tradition of sacred groves. "Sacred groves are the
embodiment of subaltern religiosity in India. They are the centres of folklore,
beliefs and taboos" (Markose 84). According to
Byju, tree lore is a vital aspect of the religiosity of the subaltern community
as the concept of 'Tree of life' was popular among the subaltern groups of
India. He also states that the subaltern community sees their religious beliefs
as highly linked with sacred forests. This can also be interpreted as their
rebellion against the Hindu fundamentalist movement, which aims to combine the
subaltern religious beliefs into the dominant religious beliefs of Hinduism. So,
the tradition of sacred groves can be understood as a subaltern effort of
eco-restoration. In the Hindu
religion, subaltern religious beliefs and practices were not recognised in
homogenisation supervised by Brahmanical cultural hegemony because of the
homogenising tendency. Subaltern eco-ethnicities are a powerful attempt that
challenges modern religious practices. It is an attempt to bring new theories
on religion and ecological restoration to the forefront. (Markose, 91)
"According to subaltern spiritual practice, the sacred is housed in the
earth, the sky and the whole universe. There is no separatism in this subaltern
consciousness, and this consciousness of wholeness dismantles modern dualistic
notions of sacred and profane, nature and culture, man
and woman, civilised and savage, etc." (Markose 94). The subaltern
religious beliefs are highly linked with ecology, and it is visible in their
lifestyles and culture. Sacred groves can be seen as a minor form of the
geographical living practices of subaltern communities, mainly the tribal
culture. The ritualistic practices in sacred groves can be considered as a
rebellion against Brahmanical ritual practices. The subaltern community
maintains their religious and cultural practices through sacred groves even in
this developing world. This is well acknowledged by Nobel Prize winner for
peace in 2004 Wangari Maathai that the different ways of ecological restoration
can be interpreted as people's struggle for survival. So along with the
religious beliefs, Kaavu gives folklorist, ecological and historical dimensions
as well. Upadhyaya
(1996) Thottam
Pattu Thottam Pattu
is a vocal ballad sung before the Theyyam performance, and it lasts for about
20 to 30 minutes, while for some deities, it lasts for about 6 to 7 hours.
Thottam is derived from Thottuka, which means creating, making, or feeling,
while some argue it is derived from Sthotram, which means a song in praise of the
deity. There are about hundreds of Thottam, and each one is different from the
other. However, there are similarities between certain Thottam. It is believed
that soon after it, the performer will be possessed by divine spirits, and then
he is accompanied by 2 or 3 members to safeguard him. They narrate the stories
of legends from the subaltern community related to the temple's deity, where
the performance takes place. Chenda and Thudi are played along with the song.
Depending on the time at which Thottam is sung, it is called by different
names. For example, the Thottam sung at noon is Uchchathottam and at dusk as
Anthi Thottam, etc. Different kinds
of Theyyam will have different kinds of Thottam Pattu. It conveys historical
and sociological perspectives as they talk about people's cultural life,
practices, and beliefs at that time. Thottam Pattu conveys caste
discrimination, slavery, and the ideological differences between upper and
lower castes. While some convey the birth of the deity, childhood, and youth of
it, and some other kinds of Thottam give descriptions of the qualities and
physical appearance of the deity. Some of them have some passages in the native
language of North Malabar and the rest in Sanskritised Malayalam. It is
considered an attempt at Sanskritization and homogenises the cultural
difference between the indigenous forms of worship and the Vedic deities. This
was done to legitimise the greatness of the indigenous and powerful deities
worshipped in kaavu, as Aryan Gods are always considered superior. Thottam
includes Varavili (Invocation), Stuthi (A song that extolls the deity), and
Sancharam (Narrates the way through which the deity has arrived at that
shrine). Thottam Pattu
also conveys the social scenario of the North Malabar when untouchability was
rigorously practised under casteism, and the role played by Theyyam. It also
narrates the great deeds of the men from the subaltern community, caste
oppression, and gender discrimination. Thottam Pattu of Pottan Theyyam and
Vishnumoorthy Theyyam mainly deals with caste oppression. The rituals and
practices of Theyyam are almost like the rituals and customs of the tribal
community. Its rhythm can be related to some of the tribal performances in
Kerala, such as Paliyanritham and Irulanritham. Sacrifice of
Animals & Pooja’s Performed Different kinds
of Pooja’s and animal sacrifices are made for different deities. Based on the
deity's appearance and character, Kaavu is classified into Shaivite,
Vaishnavite, serpent, human variety, etc. Some of the deities are wild and
terrific, so they thirst for animal blood. Goddesses like Kali, Bhagavathi and
Chamundi, etc., are manifestations of Sakthi or superpower, while gods like
Bhiravan, Vishnumoorthy, Gulikan, and Pottan, etc. represent the concepts of
Vaishnavite and Shaivite. Animal spirits are represented through Hanuman, Bali,
and Puli, etc. Blood
sacrifices are made for the deities like Kuttichathan, Karim Chamundi and
Gulikan. As it can calm down the vigorous form of deity, it was highly prevalent
among the indigenous people of Northern Kerala even before the advent of
Aryans. With the arrival of Aryans to Northern Kerala, they treated blood
sacrifice as inferior and, according to them, it is practised for Non-Sanskrit
Gods. Thus, the indigenous deities worshipped by the village people were Non
–Sanskrit Gods, and they were considered inferior to the Sanskrit Gods. The
binary of Sanskrit Gods and Non-Sanskrit Gods created many discourses. So
later, there was an appropriation of the Non-Sanskrit Gods with Sanskrit Gods
by giving them the name of Sanskrit Gods without merging the functions. Interpretation
of Makeup & Costumes Theyyam is also
one of the most visible and spectacular art forms in Kerala, along with
Kathakali, Koodiyattam, Ottamthullal, etc. Most of the necessary items used for
makeup are taken from nature. The makeup and dressing up for Theyyam is a long
process. The makeup starts with Theyyamkeeyal [7]
where the Theyyakaran [8]
(Theyyam performer) wears the Mudi. Generally, the
colours used for Mukhamezhuthu (Facial makeup) are white, red, yellow, and
green, and these colours convey various aspects. It helps in the strong
projection of Theyyam spirits, and thereby it helps to grab off the attention
of spectators. The red symbolises love, violence, bravery, and yellow denotes
sickness, ripeness, and death. Black stands for mourning, green shows innocence
and eternity, and green conveys a new life beginning. Furthermore, these bright
colours are often associated with lower castes in India. These makeups and the
costumes compliment the performer on conveying the various Bhava or emotions of
the spirit effectively when the spirits possess the performer. Through which an
intensifying performance takes place. Some of the
plants used for makeup purposes are having medical importance. Along with the
worship of Theyyam, these plants also get conserved over the years. Plants such
as Alstonia scholaris, Michelia cempaka, Azadirachta indica, Cocos nucifera,
Mimusops elengi, Ixora coccinea, Curcuma longa, and Ocimum sanctum are used for
makeup. Among them, Alstonia scholaris, Michelia cempaka, Azadirachta indica,
Cocos nucifera, Mimusops elengi, Ixora coccinea are common remedies of some
diseases like cholera, eye diseases, and fever. Role of Women As Theyyam is
always performed by men when coming to the representation of women, it can be
seen as an appropriation of women's voices. In the feudal times in Kerala, men
occupied the centre of social, cultural, and political discourses, and women
were entirely marginalised. This is well seen in Theyyam, as it is mainly
dominated by men even though goddesses outnumber God's pantheon. Women's role
is limited to the singing of Thottam except for Devakoothu 1 as women perform it. Furthermore, when
women became victims of patriarchal morality, their voices in Theyyam were
mediated through men's (mis)interpretation and are often silenced. Certain
Theyyam narrates the stories of lower caste female victims of casteism. Theyyam such as
Kadangottu Makkam, Thottumkara Bhagavathy and Muchilottu Bhagavathy depict
gender violence while Neeliyar Bhagavathy projects caste-based gender violence.
The myth of victimisation of a young beautiful lower-caste girl named Neeli for
her chastity is projected through Neeliyar Bhagavathi Theyyam. In feudal times
lower caste women were exploited by upper-caste men. Neeli was also tried to
seduce by an upper-caste person, but Neeli threatened him by saying that she
would kill him if he touched her. It led to the arousal of a manly ego in him,
so he created a fake story of the illegitimate sexual relationship of Neeli
with another man. According to the social norms of the society at that time,
they decided to decapitate her by her father. On the decapitation day, the
separated head rose into the sky, and it was seen as a Godly power. Thus, from
that day onwards, Neeli is worshipped as Neeliyar Bhagavathy in Kaavu and
through Theyyam. While the
womanly figures represented in Kadangottu Makkam and Muchilottu Bhagavathi
Theyyam experienced verbal abuse, they had to suppress it for the sake of their
family and the class and social class norms. The Brahmin women represented in
Muchilottu Bhagavathy Theyyam were highly learned, intelligent and chaste. The
men in their community had envy towards her, and they were reluctant to accept
her knowledge and individuality. So, they invited her for a talk to test her
knowledge. She answered all the questions, but the men's ego did not want her
victory over them, so they asked her to talk about the most enjoyable and
agonising experience in a crooked way. For that question, she answered sexual
experience and labour pain. The gathered men for the talk came up with false
allegations of the woman being adulterous, as a chaste woman can never speak
about sexuality. Therefore, she wanted to prove herself by setting fire on
herself. For this purpose, she asked a Vaniyan to pour some oil on her and fire
it, and the next day, the Vaniyan happened to see her in the form of Bhagavathy
in his open well. From that day onwards, she is worshipped as Muchilottu
Bhagavathy and as Kuladaivom [9] of
the Vaniyan community. Thottumkara
Bhagavathi Theyyam is an instance of brutality women face for not affirming
women's ideal image as sensitive and emotional created by the patriarchal
society. As the woman did not cry on the death of her child, and so she was
punished by putting a firepot on the head leading to her death. The Hindu forms
of Theyyam conveyed the stories of violence, and the Theyyam created by Muslims
known as Mapilla Theyyam also projected the same. A kind of Mapilla Theyyam
called Ummachi Theyyam, usually performed in Mekkattillam Kshetram (Temple in
Neeleswaram, Kerala), portrays a poor woman from the Muslim religion who had to
work in a Hindu royal household under poverty. When she was husking the paddy,
an upper-caste warrior happened to see her and verbally abused her for
polluting the rice to be served for the deity. Out of the verbal argument, the
man got angry and beat her with a stick, which led to her death. From then, she
was made Daivakkaru [10]. All these
Theyyam emphasise that men were the centre of knowledge production during the
feudal times, and with their power, they silenced the women, mainly lower caste
women. Even though Theyyam projected oppressed women's stories, they were all
by mediated men's interpretations. They were either killed, accused, or
tortured in the name of chastity, and when the acquisitions were proved wrong,
they were made as goddesses. At this point, Toril Moi's observation becomes
valid "Throughout the history, women were constructed as man's other,
denied the right to her own subjectivity and responsibility for her own
actions." This again highlights the fact that the individuality and
identity of the women were associated with the notions of chastity. However,
Poomatha Ponnamma's story is not even presented in any of the Theyyam. She
refused to meet the sexual demands of an upper-caste lord even though he
offered her a considerable quantity of rice to meet her hunger out of poverty.
Out of the manly ego, he persuaded another Pulaya woman to spread a false
gossip that the former had an illicit sexual relationship with some man. At
first, she was reluctant but later agreed. When the villagers came to know
about it according to the social norms of that time, they decided to burn her
alive. While she was burnt alive, she mockingly invited the lord to have a
sexual union in front of the villagers. She is not even treated as Theyyam
pantheon, but this story is narrated through Thottam in print format. One
reason for the absence of this story in Theyyam is that maybe they do not want
this gruesome incident to be retold through Theyyam. This can be related to the
arguments of Spivak in the essay 'Can the subaltern speak' that when the
dominant classes represent the marginalised, they always ensure that their
interests are preserved. When the men presented the stories of women through
Theyyam, they suppressed the female voices and only depicted women's stories
that conform to the patriarchal discourse. This is well reflected in the forms
mentioned above of Theyyam. Even though women perform Devakoothu 1 they narrated the stories taken from
epics, and they do not present the problems of violence that women had to face.
This conveys that the actual voices of women are entirely excluded in Theyyam. 2. OBSERVATIONS AND CONCLUSION As in feudal times, men were the centre of knowledge production and
presented things from their viewpoints. Reading Theyyam as an archive of the
subaltern community puts forth culture and traditions, but it completely
ignored women's actual voices and stories from their community. The art form is
highly linked with religious beliefs, has survived over the years, and is
giving recognition to the heroic characters presented through it. Apart from
that, it is also a way to preserve their culture and traditions. There is no
clear evidence that divinities attached with each heroic character in the
stories presented through Theyyam are true. However, they have presented the
stories of people from their community who resisted the various forms of
violence from the upper castes. They are heroes for them and can almost be
equated with God. Through Thottam Pattu, they presented their problems to
society in general. Theyyam archives every religious and spiritual aspect surrounding
their community, along with it also shows how the people have protested against the violence under casteism. With
exclusions and inclusions, Theyyam archives the subaltern community in Northern
Kerala.
Refrences Markose, B. (n. d.). Sacred Grove : Reclaiming a Subaltern Paradigm for Ecological Restoration. Moi, T. (1989). Sexual/Textual Politics, London : Routledge. Markose, B. Thomas, L. E. (2018). Rhizomatic Reflections : Discourses on Religion and Theology. Wipf and Stock Publishers, 82-90, 94-96. Payyanad, R. (1998). Folklorinu Oru Padhanapadhathi, Thrissur : Kerala Sahitya Academy. Spivak, G. C. (2021). The Rani of Sirmur : An Essay in Reading the Archives. History and Theory, JSTOR, 24(3), 247–272. https://doi.org/10.2307/2505169. Upadhyaya, U. P. (1996). Renaissance in Tulu Literature, in Coastal Karnataka, ed. Upadyaya, Uduppi. [1] Devakoothu: Theyyam
performed by women. [2] Mundya: playground [3] Kulam: Clan [4] Tamizhakam: Region coming under Tamil Nadu in the
olden times. [5] Gramadevathas: Deity worshipped by the entire village. [6] Kshetradevathas: Deities worshipped in the temple. [7] Theyyamkeeyal: An occasion where the Theyyam performer wears the headgear. [8] Theyyakaran: Theyyam
performer [9] Kuladaivom: Deity worshipped by a particular clan. [10] Daivakkaru:
Divine being.
© ShodhKosh 2021. All Rights Reserved. |